Athletic Archive Source Reliability Rubric: Rank Records, Programs, Photos, and Oral Histories
An athletic archive source reliability rubric is a scoring framework that ranks every information source contributing to a school’s athletic history—official scorebooks, printed programs, photographs, game-day rosters, and oral history interviews—so that conflicting dates, names, scores, and achievements can be resolved with documented rationale rather than individual judgment. Without a rubric, archive decisions rely on whoever is in the room: the registrar who remembers the game differently, the booster president who insists the championship year was 1987 not 1988, the retired coach whose recollection is compelling but unsupported by paper. A rubric converts those competing claims into a structured comparison with a documented outcome.
Read More
